We will be uploading the Pleadings as they unfold in this case until the final judgment is received.

Please check back or bookmark this page for regular updates.

Thanks

 

5 December 2024

Email Tim Jones, CEO, Auckland BDO (all of the prior without prejudice removed).

BDO REFUSE to participate in any form of mediation.

BIG MISTAKE – if someone has a gripe with you, you ALWAYS go to mediation. That way, at the least, you see the size of the problem you have, and at best, things are often resolved with just an apology once people see things from the other person’s perspective.

Given a copy of the billboards going up on the motorway – NO response!

View here: Jaques email to Tim Jones

 

9 April 2025

Email Emma Smith, National Communications Manager, BDO New Zealand advising of website and upcoming billboards – NO response again!

View here: Jaques email to Emma Smith

 

1 March 2026

Billboards go up on the Auckland motorway

 

Andy McKay - Ellerslie motorway, Auckland - 28 February 2026

 

Nick Innes-Jones, Rosedale motorway, Auckland - 1 March 2026

 

Tim Jones, CEO, BDO rings billboard company, “We don’t want to sue Dave. We will sue you if you don’t take them down”.

(Don’t blame them – they won’t want anything I have to say to come out in public in a Court environment!).

 

2 March 2026

BDO write a VERY heavy letter threatening the billboard company (10 out of 10 for blackmail).

View here: BDO blackmail letter to billboard company 

Billboard company writes back refusing (EXTREMELY good reply – freedom of speech, and on the face of, it can’t tell who is actually in the wrong – so why stop someone lawfully stating their piece – especially if it warns other to be careful in engaging with BDO!).

View here: Billboard company response to BDO

 

8 March 2026

It was not worth the distraction of arguing about the copyright use of the BDO logo (despite us crossing it out) so we've pulled those billboards down and put these ones up instead.

Andy McKay - Ellerslie motorway, Auckland - 8 March 2026

 

Nick Innes-Jones, Rosedale motorway, Auckland - 8 March 2026

 

As of 1 January 2026 the New Zealand High Court has adopted an "evidence first" based approach to civil claims and you must now file all the evidence and documents that you want to rely on at the same time as your Statement of Claim.

We're all on track to have ours filed and served for the end of May.

BDO then have 30 working days (about 6 weeks) to get their Statement of Defence and evidence in (and they've already disclosed most of it in the CAANZ complaints process so they're bound to stick to that).

We should stick these billboards up in June to continue the awareness of this important issue:

 

BDO June 2026 billboard

 

Shall we advertise it during the 1News time slot (since all business people watch that) like we did the SRT raffle?

Your suggestions and feedback are welcome.

 

9 March 2026

Google Analytics is showing 3,400 Active Users on the website and a massive 26,000 Event Count. 

Looks like awareness is going very good.

So many more people protected - EXCELLENT!

Google Analytics of Complaints website

 

18 March 2026

Looks like Tim Jones, CEO, BDO Auckland has made a complaint to the Advertising Standards Authority (complainant details have been omitted, but he was certainly unhappy about the billboards ringing the billboard company on the Saturday they went up).

Complaint here: BDO complaint to the ASA

Our response to the complaint here: Digital Signs response to ASA 8-3-26

This is the outcome of the complaint: ASA outcome to BDO complaint

 

20 March 2026

There is a good level of media interest in this injustice.

NBR did us the favour of publishing a copy of the Andy McKay billboard internationally.

You can view a copy here if they remove it: NBR BDO billboard article

While we have had a run-in with NBR several years ago when they refused to remove ‘click-bait’ articles that were really not newsworthy (it is only being sensationalist to headline a ‘bankrupt, truck driver, lawyer'), apart from this shameful departure from the proper business/wealth stories they usually focus on, we do recommend their subscription service to those serious about being kept informed.

The Post picked it up on 16 March 2026.

This was then picked up by Going Concern also on the 16th and Law Fuel the next day on 17 March 2026.

I thought BusinessDesk was into bringing you the current business news - but maybe I was wrong?

Not sure what you think, but if I was involved in BDO marketing I would want to be oiling that squeaky wheel?

 

23 March 2026

On 13 May 2025 BDO issued a Press Release (copy here if they since remove it) that they were the Deal Advisory to Lumo (our largest competitor, remember) in the acquistion of digital billboard company Globox!

It is clear BDO could never have assisted us to acquire Globox, to further strenthen our market position, if they were assisting Lumo to do that exact same thing!

There is a clear conflict of interest in BDO purporting to be assisting us to grow while also doing the exact same thing for our main competitor!

 

31 March 2026

BDO REFUSE to attend mediation!!!!! (not surprising really - most people avoid meetings like that when they're embarrassed about the position they're in).

On 24 March 2026 our lawyer Steve Keall (clever chap) sent an open invitation to BDO's lawyer MinterEllisonRuddWatts for BDO to attend mediation to get a better understand of what transpired and (hopefully) resolve this dispute.

Copy here: Invitation to BDO to attend mediation_24 March 2026

31 March 2026 - NOPE!

And - get this - "They have also instructed us to communicate that they are not aware of the basis for Mr Jaques’ belief that he has a legal claim against BDO" (they WOULD if they attended mediation!)

Copy here: BDO REFUSE to attend mediation

BIG MISTAKE!

Had BDO said they would sit down with me, they would have seen how this stepped through, and how events ended up in me being seriously short-changed.

TBH: I find it astonishing that BDO still seem completely oblivious to their professional obligations, even after CAANZ issued their decisions on their conduct!

If this is the case, then it is even more important than ever that the public are warned prior to considering dealing with them!

More to come soon ...

 

13 April 2026

Steve Keall has completed his legal Opinion to us and said liability is extremely clear in this case.

To put it simply, BDO was absolutely prohibited from entering into an engagement to review their own work (so everything they did after this was unlawful).

This makes complete sense, when I was a lawyer, it was my job to act in the best interests (at all times) of my client, how could I ever therefore turn on them at any time and use my skills to sink them?

There is also a claim in negligence against the BDO Auckland partnership for McKay’s Report. Not only was it inaccurate, but given McKay is an experienced liquidator, it would be virtually impossible for him to ever be able to objectively review a business opportunity (as liquidators are so immersed in even the best of ideas failing). We will have to work through that too.

He has given us a quote to prepare all that is required to file the pleadings, we have paid that money, and he is now in the process of preparing them for filing (so these will be in closer to the middle of May now, rather than the end).

I told him I was extremely concerned that BDO had written saying they had no idea what they had done wrong. Steve recommended he approach them to share our view of liability (and I have approved that).

As I have previously said the High Court has moved to a new ‘evidence first’ case management model, and reviewing that I see the very first Case Management Conference is for a half day (not the previous 30 minutes), and parties are required to be there with their lawyers!

The Court will want to know if they have attempted mediation or had any settlement discussions.

BDO are of course free to do anything they want, but it will be interesting to see what they say to the Judge when liability is so clear yet they continue to say they have no idea what they’ve done wrong?

We will upload the pleadings as they are filed in May so diary a reminder to come back and have a look then.

 

18 May 2026

Excellent progress today – Statement of Claim filed with the Auckland High Court. Receipt here

Minter Ellison have asked to engage with our lawyer to properly understand the claim (about time).

Out of respect for the process I will hold off uploading the Statement of Claim and other documents just for now, but if they don’t sort things out, then I’ll upload them when I upload their Statement of Defence.

Our primary claim is Breach of Fiduciary Duty, with 2 other causes of action in Negligence and Breach of Contract.

If you want to see a copy of the Claim prior to this give me a yell.

 

29 May 2026

The Court have returned the filed Claim so it is now ready for service.

In the meantime Minter Ellison have provided the copy we gave them to Gilbert Walker and yesterday we received our first letter from them: here

If you don’t have time to read it, you can generally describe it as a BDO “Fk You” letter.

(We do not accept this correspondence as without prejudice. It does not contain any concessions or settlement discussions).

It is astonishing that their first and biggest paragraph is them claiming their client DOES NOT owe any fiduciary obligation to their clients!

Have they not read the CAANZ Code of Ethics & Professional Standards for Members?!

Section 210 (page 40) sets out in detail every member is required to avoid operating in an actual or potential (perceived) conflict of interest (para-phrased).

See section 210.8 on Disclosure and Consent. (Upon a conflict of interest arising, it must be disclosed to the Client, to obtain informed consent as to whether one or all of the members cease acting).

How the heck can Andy McKay purport to ‘independently’ review the work of partner Nick Innes-Jones, then the moment the 2 of them get into a disagreement about it, McKay instructs Innes-Jones to stop acting for their own client and leave him to hang out to dry?

Which part of the BDO engagement provided McKay with the right to decide to stop the provision of other services and how was that ever disclosed by EITHER partner at ANY time!?

How can BDO and/or Gilbert Walker seriously write that the “breach of fiduciary duty is hopeless”?

We are SERIOUSLY concerned at such an ignorant and cavalier attitude by BDO.

Our lawyers have written back (nice letter). You might well regard this as our “Fk you back” letter if you don’t have time to read it: here

You can also download the proceedings here:

Statement of Claim

Notice of Proceeding

Initial Disclosure

High Court Proceeding Timeline

When I was a lawyer, I never had a litigation case that I would call ‘easy’ or ‘straight-forward’. It is human nature for people to dig their toes in, and it is typical that large organisations like BDO seek to use their power and connections to shut down anyone that seeks to complain about them.

Despite it clearly being a ‘David v Goliath’ situation, right from the time I walked out of McKay’s office in 2020, and I knew he was going to play up, I just accepted there was nothing I could do about it at the time, so instead I set about building my foundation of proof.

Today we have the CAANZ decision (I would not one of those against me if I was an accountant), the independent peer review of Forensic Accountant Paul Moriarity, and the valuation of losses by Sapere Research Group (this might even get up to $400m).

We have the money in the bank, and my outside interests (the build of the 4-person electric hovercraft) are coming along very nicely (to retain positive and balanced mental health during a process like this).

Rome was not built in a day, and even with the new High Court ‘evidence first’ model these things still take all of 24 months to get to a hearing and likely circa $200k on legal and expert evidence, so all you can do is buckle yourself in for the ride and deal with each matter as it arises.

BDO should take it on the chin (they’ve clearly dropped the ball) and instruct their insurers to settle it for as cheap as they can. The longer they keep trying to throw mud at one of their own clients, the more they're showing how they intend to treat any future client that is unhappy with their work.

Thank you for the messages of support that have come through. Two other Kiwis who have also had significant trouble with BDO have been in contact and once we have their material into a clear and supported form this will be uploaded under Case Studies too.

 

CAANZ Decision

CAANZ said I can "provide any one (sic) with copies" here

Decision 1 here

Decision 2 here

(apparently I cannot identify who is who)

The law can be funny at times.

 

19 June 2026

They’re back writing to us again: here

And our response: here

The good news is they’ve stopped writing on a without prejudice basis (quite good, as a serious company should not be hiding behind this when stating their position).

The other good news is their letters are likely to start slowing down now (you can’t keep bleating that it’s not your fault – they need to just get on and defend it).

Let’s have a look at what they’ve said:

·           Breach of fiduciary

-             If you agreed to BDO ‘independently reviewing’ its own work then you are bound by the outcome? 

No, sorry. Remember the facts? Kilmartin said he wanted McKay, I said, “But he works for BDO” (ie BDO can’t now say I’m a bad client after they’ve said I’m a good one?), and Kilmartin (recognizing the conflict) said, “Lucky you”. 

I was happy to McKay to review the positive cashflow forecasts Innes-Jones had done for us in 2019 as Innes-Jones was thorough and competent, and his cashflow forecasts are correct.

What I DID NOT agree to was:

-             McKay telling Innes-Jones he was to STOP working for us

-             McKay failing to follow GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting Principles) in the recording of the Halo $600k discount (remember Paul Moriarity said Innes-Jones was correct and it was McKay that was wrong?)

-             McKay focusing on historic or current accounting (ie you’re insolvent now) and not paying ANY attention to your forecast position (ie, imagine you had developed the cure for cancer. You have no money today, but you will have plenty as the contracted sales kick in? Should you be assessed as a worthless business today?).

-             McKay was supposed to confirm Innes-Jones had properly recorded our financial position, and that our forecast financial position was solid (of course it was! Innes-Jones is clever and competent!). He was not supposed to develop a bad attitude, decide he was a ‘know-it-all’ God (remember the billboard?) and impartially report on the enterprise opportunity (yeah, right, like any Liquidator could ever see a business opportunity as possible/likely).

BDO do not appear to understand (Smith likely does, he’s just playing dumb to see if it will wash) that McKay simply could not take the review engagement AT ALL in the first place, so EVERYTHING that happened after that is invalid/unlawful.

 

·           US to prove McKay was negligent

-             NOPE – you’ve missed a step!

-             If McKay did not work at the same firm as Innes-Jones (BDO), and he was not ‘senior’ to him (ie in a position to dictate to him), Innes-Jones would not have bowed down to his dictatorial rubbish, and would have kept on advocating that his position complied with GAAP, and the business was good!

-             Let’s test that theory? PWC was doing the ‘independent review’ – they said the Halo discount could not be recorded as an asset on the Balance Sheet – Innes-Jones would have pushed back, told them they were dreaming, pointed to the GAAP handling of this discount (the difference between purchase price and registered valuation), and they would have resolved it, and moved forward.

-             Is Innes-Jones competent? Yes

-             Was he right on the $600k for Halo? Yes

-             Was his 2019 forecasts showing 2021 profit correct? Yes

-             Did the business have significant barriers to entry (resource consents) and USPs (Client Portal and proven 5x $1/ad model)? Yes

-             To put it simply – there is NO WAY IN HELL any accountant could have said Innes-Jones was wrong, if they were not in a position to dictate to him and shut him down! 

 

Do you see the conflict and negligence now?

 

·           The IRD $191k PAYE debt PROVES you should not be in business

-             Ha

-             What do we know about high-growth tech companies? They’re frequently out of money.

-             What is the first thing you miss out on paying if you’re busy investing in growth? Tax (naughty).

-             Was the company under an arrangement? Yes

-             Was it honouring that arrangement until COVID hit? Yes

-             Did the IRD threaten merry hell and to liquidate the company since then? Yes

-             Did they liquidate? No

-             Is the company under an arrangement now? Yes

-             So I get it – they’re naughty, but was it managed? Yes

-             So the problem is?

 

·           You have not given enough disclosure

-             Ask me for anything you want, and you can have it for free right now (docs 55 and 70 were given the same day they whinged about it).

 

·           You’ve had so many Statutory Demands

-             That’s not true?!

-             Another Accountant quoted $4k then invoiced $17k. We paid the agreed $4k and of course we withheld the rest. He won, we lost, we paid the balance (and $12k of legal for him not counting our own lawyer). I then met for coffee with him (after he’d won) and HE apologized to ME (tbh a very immature way to resolve a conflict/difference of opinion).

-             IRD also thought a Stat Demand was a good way to collect PAYE. We ignored it (it was extremely inappropriate), started a voluntary payment, and they backed off (bullies).

-             And, don’t forget, how is any of this relevant to the BDO conflict of interest and negligence (oh, that’s right, it’s not, we’re just flinging mud to burn you off!).

-             Remember: If BDO had not absolutely stuffed up in 2020, BNZ WOULD have advanced the $10m, and we would be talking about ANY of this!

 

·           Jaques is a bankrupt (or about to be)

-             This is true.

-             And do you think I would be bankrupt if I had $10m from BNZ invested in a business with high barriers to entry and abnormally high net profit (remember Innes-Jones was dribbling at the opportunity to be selling this same business for $85m - $255m in 2019!).

-             Should I have started the Suicide Reduction Trust in 2024? Yes

-             Was it reasonable to expect the initial $250k invested, to run the $2m house raffle, so the Trust could be self-funding, would be enough to complete the raffle? Maybe

-             Should I have known MSM would push back so hard and refuse to run our paid raffle ads (instead returning the money we paid them)? Probably not

-             When it became apparent the initial $250k was insufficient, should I have put another $400k in (thinking it would come right)? Maybe

-             When it crashed and burnt, did I fess up to Wilson Parking (who were then caught up in the cashflow debacle)? Yes

-             Could Wilsons have converted the payment to a donation? Yes

-             Did they? No

-             Can they be blamed for not supporting SRT? No

-             Was it an error in judgment on my part for getting involved in SRT? Maybe

-             I do not think it is uncommon for people that have gone through PTSD in the past to want to pay it forward when they see a path (seeking a better world)?

 

The primary plaintiff is the business. Of course the business has gone to zero income. A defendant cannot usually cause a plaintiff to go to zero income then complain they don’t have the money to cover costs (so should put up security for costs).

Having said that, we’ll give them $30k if they want?

The Family Trust that owns the company has money. Keall and Cowan have been paid (and it was over $25k to put those billboards up). 

We  might have to break open the kids’ piggy banks if BDO deploy the ‘see who can run out of money first’ defence, but one way or another we will be funding this through to the end!

I’m quite looking forward to seeing Innes-Jones on the stand:

·           Are you a competent accountant? Yes

·           In 2019 you considered this a highly profitable business didn’t you? Yes

·           (not even counting you wanted to sell it, and asked what we were going to spend all the money we were about to make on)

·           The Halo $600k discount can be properly recorded on the company Balance Sheet as an equity asset according to GAAP can’t it? Yes

·           McKay was wrong saying, “No accountant in their right mind would say you can do that” wasn’t he? Yes

·           You were giving Business Advisory services to us in 2020 weren’t you? Yes

·           You attended our June 2020 Board Meeting didn’t you? Yes

·           You were giving advice on how to handle the McKay review weren’t you? Yes

·           If McKay had not directed you to stop providing services you would have kept advocating for us wouldn’t you? Yes

·           If PWC were doing the review instead of McKay, you would have comfortably demonstrated to them this was a pearler of a business wouldn’t you? Absolutely yes

·           (No further questions of this witness Your Honour)

 

(Wonder what the heck McKay thinks he going to say when he’s on the stand? Would it help if I wrote out the type of cross we’re going to level at him?)

Oh well, enough bleating for now. Our legal team has written a good letter back (‘this is all to be determined in the hearing’). 

Looking at their costs breakdown, they’re going to file a Defence then a Strike Out (I wouldn’t if I was them).

Typical bully behaviour.

Like I’ve always said, don’t jump into the fire if you can’t stand the heat.

I can stand the heat!

I’m off to Vietnam for 2 weeks Sunday (shouting myself some new teeth so that I look pretty – there’s no point going for a new hair cut!) just like my mate Simon Gault did (we can both be handsome together).

We’ve got our 6 weeks in the UK (canal boats – should be relaxing) and a few other stops (somewhere warmer than the UK 12 degree ‘summer’).

And have you seen the hovercraft photo (above)? This is really coming along now! Final measurements have lowered the air chambers by circa 200mm meaning we can really pull the waist in tighter giving some really nice extra curves to it. While the entire thing is electric (2 @ 300mm contra-rotating lift and 2 @ 400mm single thrust) we’re going to power it with 24kW 48vdc twin diesel generators rather than LiFePO4 batteries (perpetual power instead of just 30 minutes). here

Turning 60 in December – finish off this exciting year with a bang?

 

26 June 2026

Yet another letter from BDO: here

No disrespect to Mr Smith, but it’s a very poorly written letter. Why keep repeating the same thing over and over? If you’re so confident there is no arguable case, just apply to the Court to strike it out?

BTW: I have a very high level of confidence in our lawyers. While I am nobody important, I can see the basis of their legal analysis, and I agree with it completely.

It does appear there might be some refinement needed in pleading compliance (mostly in disclosure) so I’m back 5 July so we can sort that super easy then (BDO will be disappointed that there is no poison chalice in there to save them).

Not sure about you, but I’m VERY concerned BDO would ADMIT McKay paid NO attention to the positive cashflow forecasts prepared by Innes-Jones, when it was those very forecasts that proved/supported lending serviceability and enterprise viability (the central question he was being asked to answer)?!

This VERY much supports my complaint that McKay did a ‘numbers only’ assessment and not a ‘business viability’ one.

The Bank did not ask for a financial audit. They asked ‘should we lend money to this guy’. Translated into English this means, ‘is it a good business? Will it make money’.

OF COURSE it’s going to make money! The Innes-Jones forecasts show it will (and how) AND digital billboards are inherently profitable – if you build the network, advertisers will come (and we proved they would with the Hoyts, Wairau averaging $15,158.21 + GST/month!) For those that don’t know the area, Link Drive is a third tier access road behind Wairau and Target Roads, so if you can do $181,898.48 + GST/year from a third tier site, you can certainly do more from a main arterial route (and most billboards will only have overheads of well under circa 20% lease and 20% cost of finance/ROI on capital employed).

Funny, I don’t recall McKay mentioning this proof of our $1/ad model in his report, despite us having given it to him clearly? How do you spell ‘negligence’ again?

Just my luck to have landed in Vietnam in the middle of a heatwave (40 degree, feels like 44). Those poor Poms in London are also complaining there (though theirs is 23 deg ha).

Just my luck also the Dental Surgeon just zoomed ahead full speed (there is always wisdom in ‘measure twice, cut once’) and put an implant in the wrong place (and it was on the top left back molar #28 so that was as painful as anything going in). Good news is he ripped it out when he realised he’d got it wrong, the bad news it was 45 minutes later, the anaesthetic had largely worn off by then, and my toes were FAIR curling up as he stitched it back over!

I’m going to use a Litigation Funder to level the playing field with BDO. A couple have expressed strong interest so I think I’ll have one in the bag early July and they can throw a bit of weight behind this.

When I was a Litigation Lawyer I never came across a file where people were sensible. It’s good to see some things never change.

Cảm ơn bạn và giữ gìn sức khỏe nhé.

(Thank you and be safe)

 

15 July 2026

Today was the last day for BDO to file their Statement of Defence (and there did: here).

We’ve created a Table of the pleadings together: here

I would not have adopted the trial strategy BDO have (I would not deny things I know the other side are just going to be able to prove too easily. Just makes you look dodgy and a liar. Burns your credibility for when you really need it).

If you go to a lawyer, and they get to know you, do you think it’s fair they sue you later on, on behalf of another client?

They can’t (conflict of interest). They might know things about you (your financial position or attitude to conflict). 

A lawyer cannot sink their own client, and an accountant cannot either (because both have published Codes of Conduct).

If you have a read of their Statement of Defence, BDO Auckland do not believe they have to tell you if they are also helping your largest competitor dominate the market space you operate in!

(Not sure about you, but I would not want to be telling my accountant all my growth secrets if there was a chance my main competitor could learn about them and react in advance).

Also, for some strange reason BDO think they can critically review one of their own clients, and sink them if they think it is appropriate, even if they had previously thought they were worth supporting.

I hope like anything BDO are not your accountants if you start to run into trouble with IRD. They might even throw you under the bus through some misguided sense of loyalty to IRD?

From here we have to file a Reply to the BDO Affirmative Defences. 

Then we have to file a Narrative Affidavit limited to the issues (basically those above, and their limitation defences).

We’ve got that half day hearing coming up in front of a High Court Judge (I’ll be back from overseas by then).

I can’t help but wonder if the attitudes expressed by BDO Auckland are typical of those shared by BDO partnerships in other countries? I hope not!

My teeth ended up coming out really well in Vietnam (though there was that small issue with them putting the implant in the wrong place!). Flip NZ is cold that the moment (cry baby).

The generators are ordered for the hovercraft (and the body has been progressing nicely when I’ve had time).

Had my first lesson with a professional singing coach today (I need to improve my vibrato if I’m going to sing in the local retirement villages).

Otherwise, just another day in paradise eh?

 

28 July 2026

Reply to the Affirmative Defences in now: here

If you want to sue someone, you do so by filing a “Statement of Claim” in the appropriate court (size of claim and location etc).

The other side wants to deny it, so they file a “Statement of Defence”.

While they’re denying it, if they think they have a claim against you (counterclaim) or something that will knock you out of the park (“affirmative defence”) then this is where they plead that.

BDO are trying to be tricky, so they’ve pled that their Terms of Engagement (contract) prohibit us suing them (yeah right – we’ve already carefully considered this!).

They’re of course dreaming, but being desperate, they have to try all they can.

They’re dreaming because:

  • Innes-Jones did not have ANY TOE (Terms of Engagement) for the work he committed to doing (advising us to grow) in 2020 (remember in 2019 he wanted to work with us all the way to the end and be involved selling it for us?)

  • The only TOE Innes-Jones had was for 2019, and that expressly limited things to that work (forecasting) – you can’t have it both way (limit it then say it is ongoing)

  • McKay’s TOE never authorised him to interfere with the work of Innes-Jones (outside of contract, so the contract cannot be used to protect you on this conduct) (and McKay took on his work knowing Innes-Jones was in for the long-haul, so he was expressly accepting working with him from the start)

  • You cannot contract out of a ‘fatal hit’ (ie. You can agree to being hit in a boxing ring, but not to be hit so hard as to kill you there)

  • BDO was under an obligation to act in our best interests as 2019 clients (‘loyalty’). This means they could never have even entered into a second contract (McKay) if that contract was going to be in conflict with the first. You quite simply cannot contract out of the CAANZ Professional Code of Ethics (and it worries us that BDO think it acceptable to even try)

We’ve updated our Pleadings Table to show the Reply to the affirmative defences: here

 

Disclosure

One interesting thing, BDO have COMPLETELY FAILED to give us the Initial Disclosure (naughty).

They’ve said they will only give it if our lawyer undertakes NOT to give it to Jaques!

WHAT?

How can a defendant seriously expect their documents can be withheld from a key witness (who will provide information pointing out the relevant bits?).

I already know I cannot publicly disclose confidential information (I have not published any of the documents they provided in to CAANZ in the processing of our complaint). On 18 May 2026 our lawyers gave Minter Ellison (BDO’s former lawyer) a copy of our Statement of Claim on a without prejudice basis and I am on the record here saying out of respect for the process that I would hold back publishing it.

Anyway, at my suggestion I provided a signed undertaking to BDO that I would not publish anything they provide, that I do not already hold in my possession (until after they become public during the trial) and they still haven’t!

Our lawyers have written to them putting them on notice that unless they provide disclosure by 5pm this Friday then we are going to make a formal interlocutory application to the High Court requiring them to. here

(What a waste of time just to get BDO to comply with the law?!).

I’m not sure what they’re worried about? We already anticipate seeing emails between McKay and Innes-Jones arguing about the GAAP recording of the business position, McKay being wrong, and McKay telling Innes-Jones to stop being our advisory accountant (when we all know he had no right to do this).

I am not going to publish those emails – but I am going to publish this one (it was sent to me so I can do what I want with it). here (note the date)

Anyway, the pleadings are done. Steve Keall has done such a good job that no amendment to the pleadings is required. BDO have pled their position (and we have now replied).

The next step is a narrative affidavit as to the issues (we’ll have to get Steve to work with BDO to arrive at an agreed “Issues List”. I bet you anything BDO will want an issue of “did we owe our client a duty of loyalty” ha!)

There will be a judicial led (4 hour) ‘issues conference’ (akin to a Case Management Conference) coming up (might squeeze it in this year?), then both sides will have to start on building their list of experts (200 on each side?).

We’ve been in Perth this last fortnight and the place is a real pleasure to visit (5-7 degrees warmer than Aotearoa, which is nice). We cycled all around South Perth (fantastic Sir John Key vision shared pathways) and today is a dinner cruise on the Murray River.

Saturday we’re off to putter around the UK canals in our narrow boat. It was going to cost us NZD$1,000.00 (£10/day/ea) to hire 2 bikes for the 3 weeks so we went and bought 2 for $20/ea ($40), lubed and adjusted them, then collapsed and shrink wrapped them, and they’ve travelled for free (although ‘over-size’) as luggage. We will donate them to a charity before we leave but really looking forward to the puttering (3 mph) and flicking down to the local pub for a meal (lunch or dinner is fine).

Should I put a banner on my boat asking if anyone has had trouble with BDO UK/Europe while I’m there? (Probably should).

I’ve had 2 more calls from VERY unhappy campers in NZ telling me how BDO have thrown them under the bus (one in Takapuna and one in Tauranga) so these might be published soon.

 

20 August 2026

I don’t think BDO are liking how the law and facts are unfolding in this case! You can see them hanging their hopes on us not having the money to fund this (NOPE), us falling into the trap of arguing security for costs (NOPE), and arguing matters like Initial Disclosure and parties (NOPE).

Our legal team have written back here conceding anything that was not worth arguing so that we now have a nice clear run towards a trial hearing: here

These new High Court Civil Procedure Rules are pretty interesting – timetable: here 

This includes the parties arriving at an agreed List of Issues (our draft: here).

(If you’re clever you will read between the lines and see how the issues, despite being very impartially worded, are actually painting BDO into a corner where they will drown).

You should see how any documents we now hold on this case (makes for very interesting reading): here 

I have earlier said BDO were FOOLISH to plead that Innes-Jones DID NOT say he could sell the business for a 17 multiple when EBITDA got into the $5m - $15m range (as this is just going to be too easy to prove!).

Similarly, they are crazy for saying Paul Kilmartin, BNZ did not ‘refuse to lend us $2m, saying he would lend us $10m instead’, IN FRONT of Innes-Jones, as this too is just too wild for a person to dream up on their own!

Now they’ve said Jaques (Director) and Digital Holdings (2017) Limited (shareholder) should not be a party.

While we appreciate our legal team putting these in here in the first place (likely to help us distribute the award that is coming our way in due course), we are not aware of any causes of action (legal rights to sue) where a director can claim personally for a wrong-doing to a company they were directing at the time, nor of one of where a shareholder can recover (even a derivative action, usually brought where directors are non-performing, has any remedy going back to the company, not the shareholders), so we’ve followed our own advice and instructed our lawyers to discontinue those things immediately.

BDO still have not given Initial Disclosure (does anyone, who is not a legal expert, think there is a difference between “Initial Disclosure” and “Full Disclosure”?!) - BUT, they have said they will if I expand the undertaking I’ve already given them, to include words to the effect that not only will I not publish documents received through the discovery process ahead of trial (but I can afterwards), but that I will not CAUSE anyone else to do it either (talk about PARANOID!).

Of course I will give that (and have): here 

I am not a ‘machine gun’ fighter (though I was a ‘fists’ fighter when I was in the Police, and I was a crack shot with the pistol and rifle. I won the Aurora Law staff Xmas party shooting competition also – much to the jealousy of Mandy at the time ☹). I am more of a ‘scalpel’ fighter (lots of time in planning, no visible action, then go in for just a simple little ‘cut’, in the right place, when you are ready) -all metaphorical of course (before we get anyone on the other side starting to cry with all their woke sensitivities?).  

Zelenskyy hid drones in the roof of shipping containers (Operation Spiderweb) that then took out multiple Russian air bases – now THAT’S what I’m talking about – ALWAYS attack from behind when the other side has more strength than you.

BDO can thrash around the bush like an elephant all they want, but we will not be doing that back.

BDO are not ever going to get away from the core facts in this case:

  • Innes-Jones only ever had 1 formal engagement (the 2019 cashflow forecasting), and that was limited to those services. He was the guy dribbling to ‘join the team’ (so he could charge us heaps of fees helping us build it, and get plenty more when he eventually sold it for the best price). How is he ever going to get away from the fact that he provided SO MANY professional Advisory services during 2020 (and is therefore liable for his long-term commitment, for those services, and for abruptly stopping those services without our consent?).

  • BDO Partnership are deemed by law to know everything that each one of their individual partners know. The fact that McKay was so full of himself, running around, yelling at everyone else as to how things were going to be, to fail to run a firm-wide conflict check (at all) or to properly understand the work and commitments Innes-Jones had done (and was doing on an ongoing basis), was a matter for him personally, and the Partnership cannot hide behind his poor conduct.

  • Which brings us to McKay – the Bank was asking him if the business was worth lending money to (OBVIOUSLY!). They were not asking for forensic, historic, accounting, or even for an updated Balance Sheet (or validated Balance Sheet). While all of these might count for something, they do not answer the central question: was the business viable, was it going to make money in the future, was it properly run, could the Board and Management Team properly cope with the continued rapid expansion the business was experiencing.

(I should upload the McKay Report in full – then you can just read it for yourself. If you can see the Business Case assessment, let me know and we’ll consider withdrawing the claim. If you can’t, then you can see why we’re so grumpy with BDO, and why BDO have such a BIG problem!).

The Murray River, WA was GREAT! I highly recommend it to anyone holidaying in Perth.

Today I am the “Captain of my own Ship” (albeit with only 2 PAX onboard ha): here. We’re navigating the UK Midlands canals for the next 3 weeks (give us a wave out if you see the Kiwi flag and BDO banner on the side). Then we’re down to Bali for a fortnight on our way back home (another nice and warm place!). With the Danube River running so low that a cruise ship got stuck, we might have to be very careful where we put our boat (lucky I’m renowned for clever forward planning and research ha).

According to Doug’s letter, BDO should be giving us their disclosed documents this week (likely to open our eyes to a few more internal communications that will drive the nail in even further), and they should be collaborating with Steve Keall (Snr Barrister) as to an agreed Issues List.

Let’s see if they can do that properly?

We have to have our Evidence in by 1 September (which we will) and BDO have to have theirs in by 4 Novmeber (can't wait to see what those lying toads put in).

Make sure you check back for a read.

 

24 August 2026

BDO gave us their Initial Disclosure today.

No wonder they were so reluctant to give it!

There's plenty of meat in here!

I've completed my Evidence and that is out for review now so check back later this week to have a read.

If you want a copy of any of my docs please flick me a DM.

 

1 September 2026

Wrap your chops around this (redacted to better comply with undertaking): Dave's Evidence

I just can't believe it!

 

17 September 2026

BDO won’t stop writing to us!

It appears they’re running the “Insurance 101” playbook (of complaining about everything).

A law colleague also has a case with Gilbert Walker and he has said they’re trying the same tricks on him.

11 September 2026 they want me to remove half of my evidence: here

(Obviously that is not going to happen. We will be calling the author of each report - so that won’t be hearsay, and I have to give evidence on each decision we’ve made – as they’re going to claim I was negligent).

Interesting how BDO consider it OK to now be spending all of their effort calling their client incompetent? Where is the respect they were saying when they WANTED me as a client?!

To help focus the evidence, and for the JIC (Judicial Issues Conference) coming up, our lawyer put forward a draft Issues List. We won’t publish that yet out of respect for the process, and because it is still an emerging draft (though we’re allowed to – we created it).

Similar to all the other “death by a thousand cuts” defence they’re running, I see BDO have [foolishly] attempted to get us to agree to cutting out all the serious issues they face? here

We’ve made prompt and direct concessions on the points that are not worth arguing (discontinuing parties etc), but we will not be conceding to these other delusional requests (that we cease our claim against Messr Innes-Jones and McKay personally and just focus on the BDO Auckland partnership).

I wonder when THEY will realise the power of poo they’re in (they certainly don’t seem to realise so far?).

Perth was pretty (though a little cold). The UK was fantastic (shorts and t-shirt every day). After the canal boat we flicked up to the Scottish Highlands and inadvertently saw the Hogwart’s Express steam over the viaduct (and of course we then took the obligatory photo at Platform 93/4 for our daughter). The west coast of Wales is very pretty (especially the Fishguard port).

With all the talk of knives and scalpels I finally decided to shout myself my knife tattoo on my forearm. Being retired I no longer need to hedge against unconscious bias of lawyers or professional business people so I can now proudly show this dimension of my personality publicly.

Now that I’m back I get to keep playing with my hovercraft (YAY). I was really surprised that putting only 1 layer of 200g cross-weave matting with epoxy resin on either side of a 20mm poly panel brings it up to circa 80% of the torsion strength of a 18mm MDF (but only 5% of the weight, and of course waterproof!). This thing is going to be floating and flying in no time!

I’ll post the Issues List once we reach agreement on that (as a number of lawyers and others are super interested in the technical aspect of this case), and of course 4 November is not far away for their evidence (I wonder if they’re going to stick with the ‘deny, deny, deny’ defence, despite the weight of evidence?).

 

24 September 2026

As part of the new High Court process we have to file a draft Chronology.

Gee Steve has done a good job at this! Have a read: here

 

30 September 2026

BDO MISLED THE CAANZ PCC (PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT COMMITTEE)

It's one thing to be in trouble in one's profession. It is quite another to deliberately mislead the Professional Conduct Committee tasked with investigating the complaint and upholding the standard of the profession!

It is my opinion both Innes-Jones and McKay have deliberately misled the Committee by withholding material contemporaneous communication and stating untrue facts.

I am going to make a fresh complaint against each person to CAANZ.

It is of critical importance that the PCC of CAANZ can trust what they are being told by their so called 'professionals' so I anticipate them to be extremely upset when they learn of critical information being withheld from them (which perpetuated the lie being told).

They will get to see it this time around (as each person will have to swear nothing is being withheld, and if they do withhold anything they will have committed perjury).

I wonder what the PCC and CAANZ will think when they learn the truth about this matter?

VERY disappointing!

Basically bringing the entire profession into disrepute, and making a mockery out of the Code of Ethics.

 

4 November 2026

Well now we get to the interesting part of the case!

BDO have to commit themselves to a public strategy (to deny it, or fall on their sword).

Guess which one they picked?

You can read their evidence here:

Paul Kilmartin (BNZ Bank Manager)

Nick Innes-Jones, BDO Partner 1

Andy McKay, BDO Partner 2

It is quite a surreal feeling reading this. 

On one hand I was there, but on reading these you would think we are all talking about completely different events?

It is likely each gentlemen wrote their own first draft (oh what I’d give to see those!), but then Legal have spent HOURS going over them with a very fine tooth comb to remove anything that might give an opening for cross-examination.

End result: a very pretty, nicely worded commentary, that on the face of it sounds absolutely perfect.

And the problem with that?

It simply does not correlate to the contemporaneous emails, communication and conduct at the time!

For example, when Gilbert Walker provided the briefs (here) they went to great lengths to ensure NONE of their disclosure (internal emails) are published.

Why did they do that?

What is the harm in publishing ordinary emails (unless those emails actually say something else?).

All I can say is we need to get into Court as soon as we can. I need to be put on the stand and they need to fire all the bullets they can at me. It is not going to take long for their ‘pretty picture’ to unwind (Paul Kilmartin, Bank of New Zealand Bank Manager says he was told by Andy McKay, BDO that I was NOT a BDO client – so WHY WERE WE SITTING IN THE BDO EAST TAMAKI OFFICE during the 2 June meeting?!).

If you poke a big bear with stick, you have to expect them to lawyer up, pick a line, and stick to it. This doesn’t make it right of course, but it would all have to be pretty normal in the world of big boy scraps?

 

UPDATE: Gilbert Walker have emailed today complaining: here

Why do they keep insisting we do not refer to or publish emails/copies of files notes?

Sure HCR 8.30 says documents disclosed during a court case cannot be used for any other purpose, but that must relate to commercial secrets etc (ie you can’t sue your competitor then use confidential business information to win tenders etc).

I cannot think of a single reason why BDO are going to so much trouble to hide what they’ve actually said and done, especially if they are so sure they have run a straight forward operation that fully complies with the CAANZ Code of Ethics.

In one very famous court case the Judge is quoted as saying, “It is very hard to talk about there being a lot of smoke around, without someone being pretty sure there is a fire somewhere”.

Have a read of their extremely carefully worded statements (redacted as best as I could to comply), then have a read of mine, and form your own view.

This thing is rushing towards a 2 week defended hearing that will be held in public. Then there will not be any restriction on what I can say, and what I can cross-reference, in support of our claim.

For example, in my evidence (para 99) I was very explicit that McKay said he WOULD support the $2m we were wanting secured against our properties. At para 68 of his evidence McKay now says he cannot recall ANY of the details of this meeting!

This won’t wash in the trial!

 

On a more positive note the hovercraft is coming along SUPER nice. Virtually all the styling is complete (full air chambers constructed and the new “V” nose is on) and I’m about 50% of the way through fibre-glassing. I’d bought a mig/tig welder a few years back and I got a guy to come around and show me how to weld aluminium so now the rear engine support structure is all welded and in. here

After chatting with a hovercraft enthusiast in the UK I decided to double my propulsion from 2 @ 400mm to 2 @ 800mm. I nearly fell out of my tree when I got the $25k quote to 3D print it all so I’ve now bought a lovely H2S printer and I’m well on my way to printing the entire thing for around $4,500.00 (tricky thing to get used to the settings though to offset shrinkage on the large parts, topple and other things).

Standing at the front of the EDF (electric ducted fans) they are styled on a jet turbine so you see all the blades of the fans just like an aeroplane rather than only 2 or 4 in traditional axial fans. Have a look at the test rig firing up: here - 58dB right next to it!

I’ve purchased a linear actuator to give me electric steering. I could not find matching dashboard gauges for the RPM/amps/temp etc so I ended up opting for the Arduino Nano running a SPT OLED display (8). I don’t have the skills to create the 3D file so I’ve outsourced that and can’t wait to print it when it’s back.

The next step will be the JIC (Judicial Issues Conference) early next year. I’ve asked the Court if the press are allowed there as I think things will start to get a little spicey now and I’ll let you know.

If we don’t speak before have a great Christmas and a happy New Year. We’ll be off down the South Island in the caravan so wave out if you see us cycling about.

 

6 November 2026

Reflection on the BDO evidence.

It’s been a day or so now and I’ve been reflecting on what the BDO evidence is telling me about the case. On how their accounts can be so different from what I recall.

Kilmartin is interesting – he is saying, “I knew the guy was trouble from the beginning (from my research). I went into that meeting knowing I’d need an independent review to see if he could be saved”.

When I was in the Wellington Police I had the highest arrest rate for false info (B109). This either meant my colleagues were asleep at the wheel, or that I was onto something. It just happened that I had a heightened “spidey sense’ and I could vibe when someone was telling me they were Mickey Mouse when they were clearly Donald Duck.

In 2020 COVID had turned traditional lending up on its ear. No-one knew which industries were going to make it and which were not. Just by chance we had brought together years of investment into complex resource consents, the Client Portal (AI) and sourcing of reliable LED hardware and we were now ready to hit the ground running with strong expansion (after investing circa $2.5m to cover losses).

When everyone (Heartland/Ricoh) were indicating ‘yes’ but finally saying ‘no’ I realized we either had to go ‘all in’ and put all our properties on the line (max out), or pack up and go home (it is very hard to trim back 12 full time staff and just do such a high energy operation scaled back).

I went into the 2 June meeting with Kilmartin at the BDO East Tamaki office with the sole objective of getting BNZ to lend me $2m against my properties. Don’t you think I would remember if it was hard going or not, and if it was looking likely or not?

How do you think I felt when the first half went as expected, but that there was then such a major shift and Kilmartin was now finally revealing how the Bank would actually SUPPORT me and partner (you need money and a good idea) to the moon and back?

Despite all of my faults, I simply am not delusional to this scale!

So what about my memory fading with time and me recalling things more favourably than they actually where? Well, that can’t be the case as I started emailing and fizzing straight away (who wouldn’t if they’d come out of that experience?!).

Then we go to McKay – 2 June Kilmartin is saying ‘let’s do this’ and 3 July McKay is saying, “grow it slowly”.

When I read McKay’s evidence, he has actually put in there everything I said! He says he has no ‘dispute’ or ‘disrespect’ of Warwick Russell (sMetric), yet he then proceeds to (in 2 places) specify why Russell did it hopelessly wrong and how therefore his plant valuation cannot be relied upon (not counting the fact there are no other importers in NZ that could have verified the Halo $1.2m installation and replacement cost).

He then repeats ‘no proven prior revenue’ multiple times. This is him using a traditional insolvency practitioner lens and looking for historic performance as an indicator of future performance. But this won’t apply to a high-growth, tech startup, that is just starting to implementing technology/IP that has taken years to perfect. In that case of course there is going to be a sharp and sudden jump in revenue as the tap is first turned on?

McKay does not deny saying he did not understand our industry (the Nike conversation). He now says he does not need to, but how is he going to have confidence in our projections if he does not even understand advertising goes UP in a recession and DOWN in a strong market (as advertisers do not need more customers)?

And let’s turn now to Innes-Jones. So let me get his story straight? He spent hardly ANY time on our projections in 2019 and really did not have any good idea about how good the business was?

Ha.

He is no clown. It is standard practice to sight supplier invoices, sales contracts (hard, written and signed commitments, not just email promises), then weight the figures accordingly. 

That is exactly what he did (and he says so in the cashflow projections!).

But Innes-Jones has to be saying this now (as the alternative creates the need for BDO to explain why Partner 1 said the business was good in 2019 but that Partner 2 said the business was bad in 2020).

Like I have said previously, Innes-Jones is not going to last more than about 1 second on the stand. When we stuck our billboards up we described him as ‘even nice guys get it wrong’ (that was before he provided this evidence lying through his teeth) we did not know how he was going to try and cover his arse. It does not matter anyway. The courtroom is EXTREMELY effective at getting to the truth through a pressure chamber.

In my opinion Innes-Jones is an optimist. By nature he is attracted to shiny things called ‘opportunities’. He is not a ‘battle seasoned warrior’ (more like McKay is) who spends more than half of his time putting out fires. 

If you recall my evidence (I can’t recall if the lawyers made me strike that bit out), but Innes-Jones started the $5m - $15m conversation by first asking, “What are you going to spend all the money you’re about to make on” and it was ME that told him to 'tai ho' his horses and not get ahead of himself.

Innes-Jones knows as well as I do that high-growth largely comes from barriers to entry. How easy your idea can be copied. The likely demand for it. How ‘passive’ the ARR (annualized recurring revenue) will be. He was not getting excited about billboards. He was getting excited about how difficult resource consents were to get (which is why we even employed our own Urban Planner in-house), that digital OOH (out of home) was a sunrise/green fields opportunity, and that our competitors were still finding their feet. 

From the DDJ experience we had an independent board. BDO was being asked to do 90 day cashflow projections on an ongoing basis (due to how high growth we were projected to be), and all manner of contingency plans were being put in place to deliver to the plans (which is why I survived the Kilmartin 2 June interrogation and the 24 July McKay one).

The 24 July meeting was meant to be 60 minutes but after only 30 McKay lifts the arm he had in a sling (due to a broken collar bone) as high as we could, and the other arm right up in the air (in a sign of defeat) and says, “Ok, Ok, we’ll support the $2m but NOT the $10m”, and NOW HE CAN’T REMEMBER THAT MEETING AT ALL?

I’m sorry – I just don’t believe him!

Call me naughty (remember all the talk about knives?) but when I’m called into the ring I actually enjoy going there. Some of us are bred for conflict and others are bred more for nurture. I am good at putting out fires and I get immense satisfaction from doing so. 

Also there is the reputational stuff that is floating around. I do not like being portrayed as a clown – when I am NOT.

(rant finished)